This would be the third pairing of Bing
Crosby and Barry Fitzgerald. They hit movie gold twice with their pairing as
priests in the landmark film Going My Way
in 1944, and as doctors in Welcome
Stranger in 1947. Paramount figured that three times was a charm, but it
was not exactly. The best part of the film was the interaction between Bing and
Barry Fitzgerald, but the script did not allow for much of the friendly banter
that was seen in their previous two films together. Personally, I feel they
should have made Bing and Barry Fitzgerald both policemen – one young and one
old – who had to settle the case of the missing Blarney Stone, using new
techniques and old techniques of investigation to crack the case. I was not
around in 1949, so Paramount was not able to ask me for my script recommendations!
Like many of Bing Crosby films, the
singing was the major draw of the film. My favorite number was Bing singing
“When Irish Eyes Are Smiling”. Bing did not record the number for the movie
soundtrack, but he did record it a few years before the film was made, on May 7, 1946.
The songwriting team of Jimmy Van Heusen and Johnny Burke were commissioned to
write new songs for the film, but only two songs were written. They wrote the
title song “Top O’ The Morning”, which was my favorite song from the film. Bing
must have liked the song too, because he sang it three times in the film. The
songwriters also wrote a pretty forgettable ballad called “You’re In Love With
Someone”, which Bing sang, and then it was sung later in the film as a duet with
Bing and Ann Blyth. Rounding out the music were traditional Irish songs like
“Kitty Coleraine”, “The Donovans”, and “Oh Tis Sweet To Think”.
Bing was in fine voice towards the end of the 1940s, and as always,
he was his charming self in the movie, so he cannot be blamed for this
misguided film. Bing did
however personally selected David Miller as director of Top O’ the
Morning. Groucho Marx recommended him to Bing. Miller had just
completed what turned out to be the final Marx Brothers’ film. It
was Love Happy, the least revered of all the Brothers’
films. I think also movie audiences were changing as television was
beginning to take hold.
Some of the
critics liked the film though:
Bing Crosby, after two lush Technicolored
musicals, has been handed a light, frothy and more moderately budgeted picture
by Paramount to cavort in, which should put him once more at the top of that
studio’s breadwinning list.
…Under David
Miller’s light-handed direction, Crosby and the rest of the cast fall right
into the spirit of the story. Groaner, despite his having to play to a gal (Ann
Blyth) who is so obviously younger, is socko. His easy way with a quip,
combined with his fine crooning of some old Irish tunes and a couple of new
ones, is solid showmanship.
…Johnny Burke
and James Van Heusen have cleffed two bright new tunes for the film, both of
which, with Crosby to introduce them, should get plenty of play. “You’re in
Love with Someone,” a ballad, has the edge but the other, “Top O’ the Morning,”
has the lilt that Crosby fans go for. Crooner also gets a chance to dispense a
round of traditional Irish airs, ranging from “Irish Eyes” to the lesser-known
but more sprightly variety.
(Variety,
July 20, 1949)
In my
opinion, Top O’ The Morning is not a great Bing Crosby movie, but even a bad
Bing film is worth viewing. The last fifteen minutes of the movie is the best,
and some of the plot is pretty sinister for a lighthearted Bing film. Bing and
the cast does the best they could with the script, and this film is worth
watching. My copy came from a showing on AMC Network in 1998, and now TCM has
also shown the film, so if you get a chance check out this slight Bing film. The
film was not great but pleasant enough..
MY RATING: 6 OUT OF 10
