Billboard liked it:Aiming at maximum holiday sales, this package of five platters brings together 10 Erin faves cut at varying times by Bing Crosby, getting vocal assist on some of the sides from the Jesters and the King's Men, while the music making belongs to Bob Haggart, Victor Young and John Scott Trotter. Der Bingle in good Erin form for each of the sides and song selections are tops ... Photo of the smiling Bing on the album cover, with notes on the singer and the songs in the accompanying booklet.
Down Beat was not impressed however saying:Bing's album, despite his usual graceful ease of interpretation, lacks his old fullness of voice. If Crosby is going to keep on making records with his evident sloppiness and lack of interest, it would be better if he would stop now and let his millions of fans remember him by his older and far better discs.
The album quickly reached No. 3 in Billboard's best-selling popular record albums chart in March 1947 and was still selling well the following year when it reached No. 1 in the same chart on 20 March 1948. It was 18th in the annual chart of top selling record albums for 1948.
Original track listing
These previously issued songs were featured on a 5-disc, 78 rpm album set, Decca Album No. A-495.
Disc 1 (23495):
A. "McNamara's Band"
B. "Dear Old Donegal"
A. "McNamara's Band"
B. "Dear Old Donegal"
Disc 2 (23786):
A. "Who Threw the Overalls in Mrs. Murphy's Chowder?" George L. Giefer December 6, 1945 the Jesters, and Bob Haggart and His Orchestra 2:27
B. "It's the Same Old Shillelagh" Pat White December 6, 1945 the Jesters, and Bob Haggart and His Orchestra 2:44
Disc 3 (23787):
A. "Did Your Mother Come From Ireland?"
B. "Where the River Shannon Flows"
Disc 4 (23788):
A. "The Rose of Tralee"
B. "When Irish Eyes Are Smiling"
Disc 5 (23789):
A. "Too-Ra-Loo-Ra-Loo-Ral"
B. "I'll Take You Home Again, Kathleen"
Interesting that Downbeat and Variety had such differing opinions. I'm a bigger fan of Bing's acting than his singing (although there are a few tunes of his that I love), but I wouldn't mind hearing "Who Threw the Overalls in Mrs. Murphy's Chowder?" Ha!
ReplyDelete